Comparison of the best 10 time tracking apps
As it becomes increasingly mandatory in Europe to record one's own working hours as well as those of employees or staff, there are more and more providers that can help make this step as easy as possible. In a constantly growing market, however, it is often difficult to maintain an overview. Therefore, our team has taken the time to give you the best possible overview of the current top 10 time tracking tools. Here you will find all the products, as well as their advantages and disadvantages in direct comparison.
Contents
- PlainStaff
- Timr
- Moco
- Clocko:do
- Ordio
- Crewmeister
- Clockin
- Papershift
- Timebutler
- Timemaster
- Comparison table
1. PlainStaff
PlainStaff is the perfect solution for companies to optimize their time tracking processes, whether for shift work, field service, project work, or general working hours. The app is very user-friendly, ensuring a quick and easy customer experience. After a brief yet detailed walkthrough, your employees can start right away, as everything operates in an extremely intuitive manner. Every feature meets all needs, making the use of the app effortless. What makes PlainStaff even more appealing is its unbeatable price.
Advantages
The app offers many features
The provider with the best price-performance ratio
The usage is very intuitive
The interface is very appealing, making the use of the time tracking app enjoyable
There is a capacity planning feature for the clear organization of all ongoing projects
Disadvantages
The shift planning feature is still new and continues to evolve
2. Timr
Timr offers exactly what one would expect. You can track work and project hours, request vacations and absences, and a bit more. However, the implementation is only moderately successful. After some practice and with the help of video tutorials, the app becomes understandable. Unfortunately, the app is anything but intuitive. Moreover, instead of feeling light and easy like a solution to a problem, the interface feels more like additional work.
Advantages
Delivers exactly what is promised to the customer
All features are easy to understand thanks to well-made tutorial videos
Disadvantages
Using the app is tedious despite good explanations
There are only a limited number of features
3. Moco
Moco is a very straightforward app that appears easy to understand at first glance. However, getting familiar with it can initially be quite tedious. While there is a comprehensive manual along with several hours of tutorial videos, anyone wanting to dive in right away will have to accept a lengthy and relatively dry learning process. Despite the higher price, you won't find more features here compared to other providers.
Advantages
The app offers customers support for acquisition
You can directly track project time for all employees
The navigation is simple and clear
Disadvantages
Shift planning is not possible
The operation is somewhat tedious at times
4. Clocko:do
Clocko is very well-equipped. It offers everything you need, whether it's shift planning, project time tracking, an overview of your data, and much more. A great addition is how Clocko allows customers to easily monitor their productivity, such as managing work hours and time management at a glance. While some of the many features offer nothing more than expected, and the numerous menu options can initially make it feel a bit overwhelming, Clocko overall provides a well-rounded app.
Advantages
There are many partners/integrations
The app delivers exactly what one would expect from a time tracking system
Disadvantages
There are no special features
Some features are poorly developed
5. Ordio
Ordio is very customer-oriented, starting with the ability to customize the homepage layout to your personal taste, followed by an integrated to-do list that can be shared and collaboratively edited with employees. The focus here is on user-friendliness, aiming to ensure that the customer actively uses the app and feels comfortable with its interface. The downside, however, is that the app is kept quite basic, meaning that apart from absence and time tracking, there aren't any significant additional features.
Advantages
The app is very customer-oriented in its usage
The interface can be customized to personal expectations
There is an integrated to-do list, which leads to increased productivity
Disadvantages
The features are lacking, and important ones are missing
The app is kept very plain
6. Crewmeister
Although Crewmeister offers a relatively limited introduction to their program, users quickly find their way around. The handling is very intuitive and therefore easy for everyone to understand. Overall, Crewmeister successfully integrates most desirable features, such as absence/work time tracking or general shift planning, into their app. However, during use, it becomes apparent that some important features, such as simple project time tracking, are notably missing.
Advantages
You can quickly find your way around the app
Using it is very easy
The most important features are well integrated
Disadvantages
Many functions, such as project time tracking, are missing
The user interface is kept very plain
7. Clockin
Clockin is an excellent solution, especially for field service tracking, such as in trades and crafts. In the mobile app, everything can be recorded easily and clearly, whether it's the customer's address, the instantly calculated travel route, or a detailed documentation of the work, including pictures of the steps and remaining tasks. Since the field service tracking feature is so brilliantly executed, the rest unfortunately feels rather lacking, and due to the few other functions, it comes across as somewhat mediocre.
Advantages
The mobile app is exceptionally well done
With the mobile app, detailed documentation of the work steps is possible
This enables excellent communication between work groups
Disadvantages
Clockin is solely specialized in field service
As a result, there are hardly any other features
8. Papershift
You can immediately tell that Papershift has been perfected for shift work. Whether for cafés, restaurants, shops, or other businesses, with Papershift, you can easily and clearly create a professional shift plan in just a few minutes. Additionally, it allows for quick responses to employee absences and intuitive plan adjustments. However, due to its focus on this one feature, Papershift is not a good alternative for companies that don't require time tracking specifically for shift work.
Advantages
Detailed shift planning is possible
The app's operation is extremely intuitive
All features are quickly understandable
Disadvantages
There are hardly any alternatives to the shift plan
9. Timebutler
Timebutler impresses with many easy-to-use features. However, navigating the app can be challenging. You are overwhelmed by far too many menu options, and it is especially difficult to maintain an overview at the beginning. Additionally, the app’s high flat rate makes it less attractive for companies with up to 50 employees. Therefore, it is more suitable for larger companies with employees who have the time to get familiar with the extensive navigation, rather than smaller businesses looking for a simple and straightforward solution.
Advantages
Man kann den Kalender mit anderen Personen synchronisieren
Die Bedienung der App fällt einem generell sehr leicht
Es werden neben normaler Zeiterfassung viele Features angeboten
Disadvantages
The navigation is incredibly unclear, leading to a tedious user experience
Unfortunately, there is poor access to other employees
Shift planning is not possible, which becomes a problem for many requirements
10. Timemaster
Timemaster approaches the time tracking issue a bit differently. The primary focus has been placed on hardware to make it as simple as possible for the user. However, with an additional software license, it is still possible to use all functions within the app. Yet, it becomes apparent once again that the emphasis has been heavily on hardware development and perfection. The app is cluttered, difficult to understand, and overall offers very little content and features.
Advantages
The focus here is on using the app in combination with the hardware
An all-in-one package is provided
Disadvantages
The implementation is rather dry
The app is very poorly equipped
As a result, the user experience is not very pleasant
Comparison table
Criteria |
---|
work time tracking |
project time tracking |
absence management |
user-friendliness |
shift work |
intuitive interface |
comprehensibility |
integrations |
price |
Plainstaff | Timr | Moco | Clocko:do | Ordio | Crewmeister | Clockin | Papershift | Timebutler | Timemaster |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
+ | 0 | + | + | 0 | + | 0 | 0 | + | 0 |
++ | + | + | + | -- | -- | 0 | -- | + | -- |
+ | + | 0 | 0 | 0 | + | + | + | + | + |
++ | 0 | + | 0 | + | + | 0 | ++ | - | - |
- | - | -- | 0 | + | + | - | ++ | -- | 0 |
+ | + | - | 0 | + | + | + | + | -- | 0 |
++ | + | - | 0 | 0 | + | + | + | - | ++ |
+ | -- | + | ++ | -- | 0 | + | ++ | - | -- |
++ | -- | -- | -- | - | - | - | 0 | 0 | 0 |